Product Information

Please allow at least 2 weeks notice for orders when possible.
If you need an order on shorter notice,  we will do our best to accommodate you.

To order,  please visit the “Contact & Order” page.

The Goods

SUGAR COOKIES
Home-baked sugar cookies are made to order and hand decorated with royal icing. Our cookies are as delicious as they are beautiful. 

CUPCAKES
Moist, delicious chocolate or vanilla cupcakes can be topped with chocolate or vanilla buttercream frosting; cream cheese buttercream, and additional flavors such as espresso, strawberry, and Oreo are available upon request.

DECORATIONS
Just provide the theme/occasion, colors, a picture of an invitation, or other inspiration, and we’ll take it from there!
Cookie icing and cupcake frosting is colored with gel food-coloring. Food- coloring markers may be used as well. Additional decorations vary depending on designs.

PACKAGING
Cookies are individually wrapped in clear sleeves and heat-sealed, then tastefully boxed.
Cupcakes are carefully boxed in either 1- or 2-dozen boxes. 

PICK-UP
Orders will need to be picked up by the customer in Whitefish Bay, WI. Delivery is not offered.  

 

Pricing

SUGAR COOKIES
Pricing starts at $40.00/dozen; sold by the dozen, up to 6 dozen.
Detailed designs may incur additional cost.
Cookies are cut out at 3/8 inch thickness and are approximately 3 – 4 inches in diameter depending on shape.
 

CUPCAKES  
Pricing starts at $38.00/dozen; sold by the dozen per flavor/frosting combination. 
Detailed designs may incur additional cost.
Mini cookies can be added to the top of cupcakes for an extra charge.

 

Ingredients

SUGAR COOKIES
COOKIE: sugar, butter, flour, baking powder, egg, vanilla

ICING: meringue powder, powdered sugar, vanilla, gel food coloring

CUPCAKES
CHOCOLATE: sugar, flour, cocoa powder,  baking soda, baking powder, salt, eggs,  vegetable oil, coffee, buttermilk, vanilla

VANILLA: sugar, flour, cornstarch,  baking powder, baking soda,  salt, butter, eggs,  vanilla, sour cream, canola oil, milk

FROSTING
VANILLA BUTTERCREAM: butter, powdered sugar, vanilla, milk

CHOCOLATE BUTTERCREAM: butter, powdered sugar, cocoa powder,
vanilla, milk

CREAM CHEESE BUTTERCREAM: butter, cream cheese, powdered sugar,
vanilla, milk

ESPRESSO BUTTERCREAM: butter, powdered sugar, espresso, milk

STRAWBERRY BUTTERCREAM: butter, powdered sugar, strawberries, milk

OREO BUTTERCREAM: Vanilla or Chocolate buttercream + Oreo cookies

 

Important Allergy Information

Second Story Bakery products are made in a private home not subject to state licensing or inspection. 
Those with nut and other food allergies should consider this when ordering; We are not an allergen-free kitchen.